Brick storefronts with awnings along Vale Avenue in Bellwater's Downtown Core as pedestrians walk past

Chamber of Commerce Convenes Employers to Tackle Hiring Pipeline Gaps


The Bellwater Chamber of Commerce convened roughly 40 employers Wednesday for its quarterly summit on the region's hiring pipeline, a meeting that revealed broad agreement on the problem and sharp disagreement on how urgently to solve it.

The Bellwater Chamber of Commerce convened its quarterly employer summit Wednesday, bringing together executives from the city’s biotech, green-energy and legacy manufacturing sectors to address what participants repeatedly called the same unresolved problem: a hiring pipeline that has not kept pace with the region’s economic recovery. Roughly 40 employers attended the session at the chamber’s downtown offices.

“We started these meetings because Kestrel and Ridgeline told us they were competing for the same three hundred people,” said Chamber of Commerce executive director Theresa Nakamura, referencing conversations that followed Kestrel Biologics’ funding round. “A year later, it is not just biotech anymore. It is everyone.”

A gap that spans industries

Representatives from Bellwater Turbine Works described struggling to fill welding and quality-control roles despite launching its own apprenticeship program earlier this year, while biotech firms reported similar shortages in laboratory and manufacturing technician roles. The timing of the summit, coming days after Bellwater Steel & Fastener Co. announced layoffs affecting 85 workers, prompted pointed questions from attendees about why the city could simultaneously have a hiring shortage in some sectors and layoffs in another.

Dr. Samuel Iyer, the Bellwater State University labor economist who moderated a panel at the summit, said the contrast is not actually a contradiction. “A 52-year-old fastener-line worker and an open lab-technician role are not interchangeable just because they both count as manufacturing jobs,” Iyer said. “Until this city’s workforce-training pipeline treats that transition as seriously as it treats attracting new employers, we are going to keep having both problems at the same time.”

Every employer in this room agrees the pipeline is broken. What we have never agreed on is whose job it is to fix it, and that disagreement has cost us at least two years we didn’t need to lose.

Dr. Samuel Iyer, Economist, Bellwater State University

Some employers want more, faster

Not every attendee left satisfied with the chamber’s approach. Nathan Pruitt, chief executive of Ridgeline Therapeutics, said he appreciated the forum but argued the quarterly cadence moves too slowly relative to the pace at which companies are losing candidates to competitors. “By the time this group agrees on a recommendation, I have already lost two more people to a bidding war,” Pruitt said. “I don’t think anyone here disagrees on the diagnosis. I think we disagree on how urgently we need to act on it.”

Nakamura acknowledged the criticism, saying the chamber is considering shifting to a monthly working group for employers directly affected by the tightest labor shortages, while keeping the broader quarterly summit for citywide coordination. “Nathan is not wrong that quarterly is slow,” she said. “We are trying to balance moving faster with not turning this into another meeting people stop showing up to.”

Dr. Ramon Delgado, president of Bellwater Community College, pointed to the college’s new partnership with Bellwater Turbine Works as evidence that individual employer-college partnerships can move faster than citywide coordination. “The fastest progress we have made on any of this came from one company and one college campus deciding to just build something together,” Delgado said. “The summit is useful for spreading that model. It is not a substitute for it.”

Gary Petrowski, the city council member representing Cedar Hollow, attended part of the session and said he left with concerns that the summit’s conversation skewed too heavily toward growth-sector employers and not enough toward displaced legacy manufacturing workers like those recently laid off at Bellwater Steel & Fastener. “I heard a lot about how hard it is to hire welders for new industries,” Petrowski said. “I heard a lot less about what happens to the welders industries are laying off. Those ought to be the same conversation.”

Nakamura said the chamber plans to invite displaced-worker advocates and community college job-placement staff to the next summit specifically in response to Petrowski’s concern. “He’s right that we have been talking mostly to the people doing the hiring,” she said. “We need the people trying to get hired in the room too.”

The summit closed with a nonbinding pledge, signed by roughly two dozen attending employers, to report their open technical positions to a shared regional job board the chamber plans to launch within the quarter. Nakamura acknowledged similar efforts have struggled to gain traction in the past. “We have tried a version of this job board twice before and watched employers stop updating it within a year,” she said. “The difference this time is that we have companies telling us they’re desperate enough to actually keep it current.”

Pruitt said he signed the pledge but remains skeptical it will meaningfully change Ridgeline’s hiring timeline. “I’ll post our openings,” he said. “I am not going to pretend a shared job board solves a problem that is really about how many welders and lab technicians this region is training every year. That number needs to go up, and a job board doesn’t do that by itself.”

Delgado said the college views the summit’s ongoing existence, whatever its pace, as valuable simply because it keeps employers and educators talking directly rather than through intermediaries. “The version of this that fails is the one where employers complain to reporters and educators read about it in the newspaper,” Delgado said. “At least here, everyone is in the same room hearing the same complaints firsthand.”